Facilities

How to vet an in-home care agency

Medicare's data covers skilled home health agencies, but the private-pay caregivers who help with bathing, meals, and company aren't in any federal rating system. For those, you're the inspector. Here's what to check.

First, the split: if you need skilled/medical home health (nursing, physical therapy), use our Home Health Checker. That's rated by Medicare. This guide is for the non-medical caregiver agencies that aren't, where quality varies widely and you have to do the vetting yourself.

Verify before you interview

Licensing. Most states license or register home care agencies; check your state's health or aging department. (Rules vary by state; your local Area Agency on Aging, free via the Eldercare Locator at 1-800-677-1116, can point you to the right registry.)
Insurance & bonding. Ask for proof the agency carries liability insurance and workers' compensation, and that caregivers are bonded. This protects you if a caregiver is hurt in the home or something goes missing.
Employees vs. contractors. Ask whether caregivers are W-2 employees (agency handles taxes, insurance, background checks, backup coverage) or independent contractors (cheaper, but more risk and paperwork falls on you).
Background checks. Confirm they run criminal background checks and how recently.

Questions that separate good agencies from the rest

Will the same caregiver come consistently, or does it rotate? (Consistency is everything for someone with memory issues.)
What happens when our caregiver is sick: who covers, and how fast?
How do you match a caregiver to my parent, and what if it's not a fit?
How are caregivers supervised: does a nurse or manager check in?
What's your minimum-hours requirement, and exactly what's included in the rate?
Can I reach a real person after hours?

Red flags

High caregiver turnover · pressure to sign a long contract · vague or shifting pricing · no clear supervision · reluctance to provide proof of insurance or references · no backup-coverage plan. Trust these signals. This person will be alone in your parent's home.

The first shift is a tryout

However careful the vetting, the real test is watching the first few visits: does the caregiver treat your parent with warmth and patience? Does your parent seem comfortable? You're not just hiring an agency. You're inviting a person into the most private part of someone's life. Trust what you see.

Licensing and insurance requirements vary by state; verify specifics with your state's regulator or Area Agency on Aging. Educational only, not legal advice.

Not sure in-home care is the right level yet?

The assessment weighs the daily needs and support gaps and tells you honestly whether in-home care fits, before you start interviewing.

Start the free assessment →

Free · No email